Welcome to Millie's Old World Meatballs & Pizza
-
185 Bricktown Way Staten Island, NY 10309 Hotline: (929) 284-4004
Welcome to Millie's Old World Meatballs & Pizza, a delightful Italian restaurant located at 185 Bricktown Way in Staten Island, NY. This cozy eatery offers a range of amenities including delivery, takeout, reservations, vegan options, and wheelchair accessibility. With a casual ambiance, moderate noise level, and free Wi-Fi, Millie's is the perfect spot for a relaxed dining experience.
At Millie's, you can indulge in a variety of delectable dishes including homemade mozzarella with imported prosciutto, eggplant parm platters, and a selection of mouth-watering desserts like almond joy and Oreo cream pie. But the real star of the show at Millie's is the meatballs. Whether you opt for the meatball ricotta hero with vodka sauce or the porterhouse steak, each dish is prepared with care and precision.
Customer reviews rave about the quality of the food and the attentive service at Millie's. From the extensive menu to the impeccable steaks, this restaurant has something for everyone. So, whether you're craving a classic Italian meal or a hearty steak, Millie's Old World Meatballs & Pizza is sure to satisfy your culinary cravings.
Good food. Nice atmosphere. Good personable service. Extensive menu. I ate the meatball ricotta hero with vodka sauce. It was tasty. I look forward to returning to try more menu items. I heard the steaks are very good.
Service and food was great. Good family oriented restaurant, love the option you can choose between coal or brick oven . Steak was perfectly cooked and waitress named Sabrina was super cordial and professional
I was suprized went my buddy said me & the guys were going there it was a Wednesday night !! not sure what to think drove by there all the time so went in w/ no expectations but was pleasantly surprised w/ the food table split everything we had salad apps all very good but the star was the porterhouse that came out boom. Sizzling plate. Didn't need any sause or fancy butter just a fork & knife. The beef was that amazing. I preidict in the next year this will be Staten islands number one rated steak on the island. Dessert was a banger too I always get a carrot cake. But my buddy had the Oreo thing was amazing next time I'll be back
Food is always great and consistent at Millies. Fresh mozz homemade def makes the pizza. Meatballs are also delish. We are dying to try the steak as well have heard nothing but good things. Been coming for years .. never a bad meal.
If you read anything from me.....read this! One of the best steaks I ever had. Millies was originally known for wood fired/coal fired pizza and meatballs. They have a nice menu of these and other italian fare. A nice atmosphere with a large bar separated by glass walls from a nice dining room. The steaks are out of this world. Top notch
A friend of mine and I went in for a late lunch. We were seated promptly and our drink order was taken we had a beer on tap they had several to choose from. We started with the char broiled oysters and an excellent salad with blue cheese candied walnuts and bacon. We also had a pizza with hot soppresad it was done in the wood fired oven For or main wr had the 42 oz porterhouse for two with creamed spinach, broccoli rabe and hash browned potatoes. Service was attentive and on point We had the chocolate moose cake and a double espresso for dessert It was a pleasure and we will be back again soon
The best steak in Staten Island by far . Great service , moderately priced , plenty of parking, all close to home on Staten Island. No need to go outside the borough for a great steak anymore .
Service is quick and friendly. Food was delicious. Had the arugula salad with craisans, ricotta salata, apples with delicious raspberry vinaigrette. Had the meatballs with vodka sauce. Delicious, and I normally don't eat meatballs out. Fresh hot soppresata brick oven pizza. I was already stuffed but had to have the pizza. Dessert comes with it, I took it home for tomorrow. Restaurant looks classy and clean.
Ive been to Millie's multiple times since my first review in 2019. Each time the food is great and PLENTIFUL. They really do feed you here like your Italian grandmother would for cheap! The prix fixe menu is what keeps me coming back. As of now its around $26 for a huge salad, meatballs in sauce, a personal pizza, and a cannoli. Not bad at all! I could eat but never able to finish everything here. You have to try the Arcadian salad! Its an Arcadian mix with candied walnuts, crumbled gorgonzola, apricot vinaigrette, topped with red onions & applewood smoked bacon. The bacon is what makes this salad. Thick cut and crispy. The meat balls are good. Cant go wrong with either their marinara sauce or creamy vodka sauce. Not exactly your Nonna's Sunday meatballs but these get the job done. Cant forget the pizza either. Having tried various pies here from the white pie, vodka pie, Margherita and others its obvious they know what they're doing here. Not many coal ovens on Staten Island to begin with so when I See it noted on the menu you know I had to go with coal as it adds a unique flavor to the pizza you won't find around. Top quality food. Eat here!
